17 Comments
User's avatar
book inc's avatar

Love the stand-up comparison! This is great, thanks!

Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

Right? I thought he summed it up perfectly.

Jeanine Kitchel's avatar

Thanks for the shout out, Jennifer. At SBWC on the panel about mktg I sat on, last ? was what would you say was most important in the entire pub process. You can guess my answer: Editing by a competent editor. Then I encapsulated what was said in your previous post about having my fiction edited by you. It's kind of amazing that somehow we writers have a blindspot that must be noticed by someone else, ie - editor. Again, thank you! You made my books so so so much more readable-- a fast read as some describe it. Yay!

Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

Imagine how surprised I was when my content editor pointed out missing or repeated things in my manuscript...stuff I normally point out to others! 😃

Jeanine Kitchel's avatar

Amazing! But so good you lived and acted on what your job is and does!

Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

I had to delete one whole chapter, but I added the best parts of it elsewhere. We compromised! :)

All Things Reconsidered's avatar

Kudos for hitting those BIG numbers Jennifer, you're on fire! And you totally deserve all the praise and support from your readers, clients and fans! (Me included.)

JUDY REEVES's avatar

Why I love R&C groups and usually have one going--facilitating one and participating in another. (Right now the participation part is missing as I struggle to get traction on a new project.).

Love reading you and Eric dialoguing about writing. Also, Eric's books! Highly recommend both of them. He creates the most interesting and quirky characters.

Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

Glas to know you found it of interest. I have one with Leslie scheduled for July. You appear in that one but maybe you've got your own editing story to share euth my readers? Doesn't have to be about me, of course. Just a positive experience or a lesson learned.

JUDY REEVES's avatar

I look forward to reading your dialogue with Leslie. Let me consider an editor story to share. All my experiences with you have been positive and so many lessons learned (still learning).

Maya de Silva Chafe's avatar

Such a right-on comparison!

Dan Tricarico's avatar

What a perfect analogy! Every writer - from fiction to stand-up - needs to try the work out in front of an audience (at least a smaller one) before it's ready for the masses.

Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

You know I agree! I loved the analogy.

Helen Landalf's avatar

I agree with Eric. The writer is simply too close to their own work to see it from that bird's-eye view.

Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

Exactly right. Even editors need editors.